ARTICLES
The
unconstitutionality of the offence of
possession of property reasonably
suspected of being stolen
Esther Gumboh
This article is an exposition of section 329 of the Malawian
Penal Code which renders a person liable to punishment if he
or she fails to give a satisfactory explanation of his or
her possession of property reasonably suspected of being
stolen. It critiques the nature and elements of this offence
and argues that the offence is unconstitutional, because it
severely impinges upon the doctrine of the rule of law,
especially the principle of legality, and the right to a
fair trial, particularly the presumption of innocence and
the right to remain silent. Since this offence is neither
necessary nor reasonable in a free and democratic society,
it is argued that it should be decriminalised.
The capital adequacy regime for banks in
Malawi
Lynda Chilinkhwambe
This article reviews the capital adequacy regime for banks
in Malawi. The Reserve Bank of Malawi is the single
all-important regulator and supervisor of the banking sector
in Malawi. Banks finance their business from customer
deposits which they invest to get a return for their
shareholders or indeed to further their lending business.
Any investment portfolio comes with risks which, if not
properly managed, may lead to great losses to the bank
concerned, the public and the economy as a whole. The need
to regulate and supervise banks therefore arises to
safeguard the interests of depositors and to ensure the
safety, soundness and stability of the financial system. The
central feature of regulation is capital adequacy, because
capital provides a cushion for losses and a buffer for
deposit insurance, and controls excessive risk taking by
banks. Currently, the capital adequacy framework for banks
in Malawi covers credit risk only as provided in the Banking
Act 1989 and the Directive on Banks Minimum Capital Ratios
issued by the Reserve Bank of Malawi which is aligned to the
1988 Basel Capital Accord. The Reserve Bank of Malawi
employs a risk-based approach to supervision covering both
onsite and offsite surveillance. Although the focus of this
article is on capital adequacy, it recognises that capital
adequacy on itself is not enough to achieve a safe and sound
financial system: capital adequacy must be supplemented with
robust risk management and efficient corporate governance.
Tackling threats to the
existence of the SADC Tribunal: A critique
of perilously ambiguous provisions in the
SADC Treaty and the Protocol on the SADC
Tribunal
Solomon T Ebobrah
Following the controversy that accompanied Zimbabwe’s
declaration that it would not comply with the decision of
the SADC Tribunal against it in the Campbell case and the
refusal of the Zimbabwean municipal courts to implement the
decisions of the SADC Tribunal, the Tribunal faces threats
to its existence. While some of those threats are external,
others are located within the founding instruments of the
Tribunal. Specifically, certain ambiguities in some
provisions have been raised to challenge the legality,
competence and legitimacy of the SADC Tribunal. This article
examines the concept of ambiguity in international legal
drafting and analyses the relevant instruments of the SADC
Tribunal. The article takes the view that most of the
ambiguities currently found in the relevant instruments are
not fatal. However, it stresses the need for Treaty
amendments to address them in order to prevent future
disruptive challenges to the Tribunal’s existence.
Romancing the foe:
The HIV epidemic and the case for a
pragmatic
stance on prostitution and illicit drug
use in Nigeria
Babafemi Odunsi
This article examines the interplay between prostitution,
injection drug use and the spread of HIV/Aids in Nigeria. It
also considers how Nigerian criminal law and the unfriendly
social attitude to prostitution and illicit drug use vitiate
the control of HIV/Aids. The article stresses the need for
Nigerian criminal law to maintain a ‘soft stance’ on sex
workers and drug users in order to accommodate their needs
and vulnerabilities relating to HIV/Aids. It underscores the
need to put the overall public health interest in
effectively controlling the spread of HIV over and above the
social aversion to prostitution and illicit drug use – an
aversion which Nigerian criminal law reflects and
reinforces.
The legislature,
tenure security and democratic stability
in Nigeria
Victoria E Onuoha and
Gabriel Omo Arishe
This article critically analyses sections 64(3) and 68(1)(g)
of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
Section 64(3) empowers the President to call the first
sitting of the National Assembly and to dissolve it every
four years from the date of the first sitting. Section
68(1)(g) prohibits legislators from crossing the floor
during the tenure of their office. We argue that section
64(3) intrinsically undermines, and has been used in
practice by the executive to undermine, the independence of
the National Assembly, while section 68(1)(g) has been used
by the ruling party to weaken the opposition in the National
Assembly, thereby stifling the horizontal accountability of
the executive. The fact that the anti-defection clause does
not apply to elected executive officials means that those
officials can defect from the parties on whose platform they
were voted into power to other political parties, without
seeking a fresh mandate from the electorate. This loophole
has the effect of the ruling party undermining the
opposition parties. It is argued that Nigeria’s brand of
democracy is far from being stable. Consequently, this
article makes a case for the review of these constitutional
provisions in order to guarantee the independence of the
National Assembly and ensure the electoral and horizontal
accountability of the executive.
Environmental
rights: A case study of the 1999
Constitution of the Federal Republic of
Nigeria
Olubayo Oluduro
Nigeria generates billions of dollars from oil exploration
yearly. Yet the Niger-Delta communities, where oil
prospecting activities take place, have continued to suffer
from the effects of environmental degradation. The laws in
place have been ineffective in protecting the rights to a
suitable environment of the people in that region. As a
consequence, human rights abuses in the Nigerian oil
producing communities have continued to take place despite
the transition from a military to a civilian regime in 1999.
This article ponders over the question of the extent to
which the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of
Nigeria and other laws of Nigeria protect the environment.
The right to a healthy environment requires the government
to ensure that natural resources are exploited and used
sustainably without sacrificing the environment, and to
regulate the activities of oil companies so that they do not
cause damage to the environment. An appraisal of the
existing laws and evolving mechanisms for the enforcement of
environmental rights in Nigeria reveals a need for a more
effective legal framework for environmental justice in
Nigeria.